The Capex Case Before March: How Finance Reads a Steam Payback

A steam-saving payback reaches finance as one line. Before 31 March they check three numbers first: the steam cost per tonne, the running hours, and how the saving will be measured.

Control valves with their actuators packed in a carton, tagged and ready for dispatch
On this page
  1. 1. Which steam cost per tonne?
  2. 2. How many hours, really?
  3. 3. How will we know it worked?
  4. The question behind the three: what is the worst case?
  5. Count capital once
  6. If capital is the blocker
  7. What we need from you

A steam-saving project usually reaches the finance office as one line: saves so many lakh a year, pays back in so many months. In the weeks before the financial year closes on 31 March, that line is read by someone who never walked the plant. They check three numbers first, and most proposals that fail, fail there, not on the engineering.

The plant engineer’s arithmetic is short:

  • Rs a year = steam saved in kg/h × running hours a year × steam cost in Rs per tonne ÷ 1,000.
  • Payback in months = investment ÷ Rs a year × 12.

Every input in that chain is a question finance will ask. Answer them in the proposal, and the line survives the meeting.

1. Which steam cost per tonne?

Ask a plant what its steam costs and you usually get the fuel bill divided by the steam meter. The lesson on the true cost of steam builds the full figure layer by layer for its practice plant: about Rs 600 a tonne on fuel alone, about Rs 820 with water, treatment, electricity, people, maintenance and capital added.

Neither is the right price for a saving. When a tonne of steam is avoided, the fuel, water, treatment and a little electricity fall. The operators’ salaries and the boiler’s instalments do not. That marginal cost is about Rs 650 to 700 a tonne at the practice plant.

The same project, 500 kg/h saved over 20 hours a day all year, about 3,650 t:

  • at the fuel-only cost: about Rs 21.9 lakh a year, 11 % too low;
  • at the marginal cost: about Rs 24.6 lakh a year, the defensible figure;
  • at the full cost: about Rs 29.9 lakh a year, 21 % too high.

Finance knows which layers are fixed. A saving priced at the full cost is the fastest way to lose the next project too.

2. How many hours, really?

The saving is directly proportional to the hours. A recovery that runs 16 hours a day saves two thirds of one that runs 24. Finance will ask what the hours figure is and where it came from.

Two things catch proposals out. First, a recovered stream saves money only in the hours when its source and its user run together: flash from a batch plant that stops at night saves nothing at night. Second, factors without a name. One proposal multiplied 24 hours × 350 days by an unexplained 0.5, which gives 4,200 effective hours a year. The factor may well have been right. Nobody reading the sheet could tell.

Write the hours as the overlap of source and user, with the basis beside it: shift pattern, shutdown days, part-load hours.

3. How will we know it worked?

This is the question that decides whether finance believes the first two. A saving is the gap between what the plant burned and what it would have burned without the project, and no meter reads the second number directly. The lesson on proving the savings sets out the method: a baseline fixed before the work, on the meters that will judge it, normalised per tonne of product, and checked again at three months, twelve months and then yearly.

The Rajkot corrugator shows what that looks like on one page: a baseline of 136 kg of fuel per tonne of product over eight months, then a retrofit that held about 15 % fuel saving over seven metered months, 20.6 % in the best month. A number like that does not need defending at the year-end review.

The question behind the three: what is the worst case?

Finance also asks what happens if it does not work. The best answer is a tie-in where the worst case is the plant as it is today. In the agrochemical flash-recovery project, the Jetomat went in parallel with the existing pressure-reducing station, which stayed for start-up, standby and top-up. On a bad day, the plant was back where it started.

Count capital once

Errors run both ways. One feasibility sheet deducted a depreciation charge from the annual saving and then divided the investment by that reduced saving. The capital was counted twice. Worked from the sheet’s own figures without the deduction, a stated payback of 3.5 years became about 2.6 years. Another priced the saving at a steam cost that already carried interest and depreciation on the new plant, then divided by the same investment again.

A simple payback divides the investment by a saving with no capital charge inside it. How depreciation and tax then treat the project is your finance team’s call. Ask them; do not build it into the engineering sheet.

If capital is the blocker

Sometimes the case is sound and the budget is spent. For some recovery projects we offer a shared-savings structure: the equipment goes in without upfront capital, the saving is measured on a dedicated steam flow meter and shared, and the equipment passes to the plant at the end. It only works when the baseline and the meter are agreed first, which is section 3 again.

What we need from you

Send us your steam cost per tonne and what it includes, the running hours of the steam source and the user, the saving in kg/h and how it was worked out, twelve months of fuel and production figures, and the meters you already have. We will tell you whether the payback will survive your finance team’s questions.

FAQ

Which steam cost should a payback use?

The marginal cost: fuel, water, treatment and a little electricity, the layers that actually fall when a tonne of steam is avoided. Salaries and the boiler's instalments do not fall, so a saving priced at the full cost gets caught.

Should depreciation be deducted from the saving before working out the payback?

Not in a simple payback. Deducting it from the saving and then dividing the investment by that saving counts the capital twice. How depreciation and tax treat the project is a question for your finance team.

What if there is no capital left in this year's budget?

For some recovery projects we offer a shared-savings structure: the equipment goes in without upfront capital, the saving is measured on a dedicated steam flow meter and shared, and the equipment passes to the plant at the end.

Find out what your steam system could save

Share a few details about your plant. Our engineers will review your steam and condensate system and come back with a no-obligation assessment of the savings and payback.