How to Check a Steam-Saving Proposal, Ours Included: Five Ten-Minute Tests

Five arithmetic tests any plant engineer can run on a steam-saving proposal in ten minutes: flash from the steam tables, measured pressure, the sink ceiling, units, and fuel against steam.

A small horizontal steam boiler with its burner, valves and gauges in a boiler house
On this page
  1. 1. Is the flash percentage from the steam tables?
  2. 2. Was the pressure measured, or assumed?
  3. 3. Is the saving bigger than the place it goes?
  4. 4. Are the units consistent?
  5. 5. Does the fuel add up to the steam?
  6. Why we check our own proposals the same way
  7. What we need from you

A steam-saving proposal is a set of numbers someone else has worked out for your plant. Most of the ones that go wrong do not go wrong on the technology. They go wrong on arithmetic you can check yourself in ten minutes.

Every example below comes from a real proposal, with the names taken off. Some were wrong by a few per cent. One claimed two and a half times more heat than the plant could physically use. None of them needed a consultant to catch, just a steam table, a calculator and an infrared thermometer.

Run these tests on every proposal that lands on your desk. Run them on ours too.

1. Is the flash percentage from the steam tables?

When hot condensate drops to a lower pressure, part of it flashes to steam. How much is fixed by physics: the drop in the liquid’s heat content between the two pressures, divided by the latent heat at the lower one. It is not a matter of opinion or of equipment.

In one proposal, condensate going from about 9 bar g to about 1 bar g was put at 9.3 % flash. The steam tables give 11.6 %. The same proposal then counted one stream of flash twice, once at each stage of a two-stage system. It claimed 509 kg/h of recovered steam. Worked through properly, the figure is about 430 kg/h.

The check: take each pressure pair in the proposal, look up both values in a steam table, and work the percentage out yourself. Then make sure each kilogram of condensate is counted once.

2. Was the pressure measured, or assumed?

A flash calculation is only as good as the pressure it starts from. In another case the sheet assumed condensate at 9 bar g and worked out 11.8 % flash, worth 1,765 kg/h. An infrared reading at the trap inlets showed 145 to 156 °C. In saturated condensate that means roughly 3 to 5 bar g, not 9. At 5 bar g the flash is 7.4 %, well under two thirds of the claim.

The check: point an infrared thermometer at the pipe just upstream of a few traps. Turn the temperature into a pressure with the steam table. If it does not match the pressure in the proposal, the flash figure is wrong too.

3. Is the saving bigger than the place it goes?

Recovered heat has to go somewhere. If flash and condensate end up in an open feed tank, the most they can save is the heat needed to warm the feed water from its make-up temperature to 100 °C. Nothing more.

One proposal sent everything to the feed tank of a 2,000 kg/h boiler, with make-up water at 30 °C. The ceiling is 2,000 × (100 − 30) = 140,000 kcal/h. The proposal claimed 355,950 kcal/h, about two and a half times what the tank could take. It also returned more condensate and flash, 2,625 kg/h, than the boiler could make in the first place.

The check: find where the recovered heat ends up. Work out the most that place can absorb. The claimed saving must be smaller.

4. Are the units consistent?

Unit slips are quiet. They do not look wrong; they just move the answer. In one fuel-saving sheet, the saving in kilograms was divided by the oil’s specific gravity, 0.9, which turns kilograms into litres, and the result was then costed per kilogram. The saving came out 11 % too high, and the payback of 4.4 months was really about 4.9 months.

Another sheet entered a boiler’s 21 t/h as 21 kg/h. Corrected, the “reduction” it claimed turned into the opposite.

The check: follow one number through the sheet with its unit written beside it at every step: kg or litres, kg/h or t/h, kcal or kJ, hours a year. The unit must come out right at the end.

5. Does the fuel add up to the steam?

Any baseline has to square with the fuel bill. A boiler cannot make more steam than its fuel allows. One audit started from 100 t of steam a day on 5,738 litres of oil a day. That is 17.4 kg of steam per litre. The boiler measured 10 to 10.2 kg per litre, and the physical limit for that fuel is around 15. At the measured figure, the oil makes only about 58 t a day.

The check: divide the steam the proposal says you make by the fuel you actually burn. Compare it with what your boiler does on test. If the baseline steam is more than the fuel can make, every saving built on it is too large.

Why we check our own proposals the same way

Each of these slips makes a saving look larger, and a larger saving is easier to sell. That is exactly why they need checking. The way to stand behind a number after the work is done is to measure it the way the Rajkot corrugator was measured: a baseline fixed before the work, fuel per tonne, over several months. The lesson on proving the savings walks through it.

What we need from you

If you want a second opinion on a proposal, ours or anyone’s, send the proposal with your steam pressures, the condensate flows it relies on, your boiler capacity and daily fuel use, and the make-up water temperature. We will tell you which numbers hold.

FAQ

Do I need software to run these checks?

No. A steam table, a calculator and an infrared thermometer cover all five. Each check takes a few minutes once you have the proposal's numbers in front of you.

What if a proposal fails one check?

Ask the supplier to show the working. An honest slip gets corrected in a day. The saving usually gets smaller, and the project may still be worth doing at the corrected number.

Will i-Kcal check a proposal from another supplier?

Yes. Send it with your steam pressures, condensate flows and boiler data, and we will tell you which numbers hold and which do not.

Find out what your steam system could save

Share a few details about your plant. Our engineers will review your steam and condensate system and come back with a no-obligation assessment of the savings and payback.