Double Counting: When Flash, Condensate and Blowdown Savings Are the Same Heat
Flash recovery, condensate return, blowdown heat recovery and the feed tank often claim the same kilocalories. Five ways a stacked steam saving counts heat twice, and the order to add them in.
On this page
- 1. The flash is counted again inside the condensate
- 2. Flash steam credited for heat its condensate gives back again
- 3. Flash and condensate both heating the same cold water
- 4. Blowdown: cut it, flash it, then use what remains
- 5. Cutting a stream and recovering the same stream
- The order that keeps the total honest
- What we need from you
A proposal lists four savings: flash recovery, condensate return, blowdown heat recovery and a hotter feed tank. Each line is worked out correctly on its own. Added together, the total can be more heat than the plant ever had to give, because the lines are drawing on the same kilocalories.
Two of the plainest slips, one flash stream counted at both stages of a cascade and a feed tank asked to absorb two and a half times what it can, are in how to check a steam-saving proposal. This post is about the quieter version: different measures, each sensible, that end up claiming the same heat. Every example is from a real proposal or audit, with the names taken off.
1. The flash is counted again inside the condensate
One proposal had about 4,690 kg/h of condensate. It flashed 6.94 %, about 325 kg/h, and credited that as flash recovery. The condensate-return line then credited 70 % of the condensate measured before flashing: 3,281 kg/h. About 228 kg/h of the flash was counted twice. On the condensate actually left after flashing, 70 % is about 3,054 kg/h.
The check: credit the return on the condensate left after the flash, never on the flow before it.
2. Flash steam credited for heat its condensate gives back again
Another proposal sent 390 kg/h of flash at about 2 bar g to an air-heater preheat chamber. It credited each kilogram with its total heat above 25 °C water: 623.92 kcal/kg, or 243,329 kcal/h. But the chamber gives the air only the latent heat, 515.07 kcal/kg. The hot condensate leaves the chamber, and the same proposal credited it again as condensate return. On a latent-only basis the flash is worth 200,877 kcal/h, so about 42,000 kcal/h was counted twice.
The same proposal also credited condensate return that the existing heater already sent to the feed tank. A saving the plant already has is not a new one.
3. Flash and condensate both heating the same cold water
Back to the first proposal. The only place it offered for its flash was a deaerator head on the feed tank, and the flash was worth about 1.98 lakh kcal/h. Its condensate return was worth about 1.97 lakh kcal/h. Both were real heat. Both were going to the same place.
To condense 1.98 lakh kcal/h by warming make-up water from 35 to 95 °C takes about 3,300 kg/h of cold water. On the proposal’s own figures, the plant’s cold make-up was about 3,281 kg/h, and that was exactly the water the condensate return would replace. With both installed, the tank would sit near 95 to 100 °C and could not condense most of the flash.
A feed tank or deaerator has one appetite. The food factory that closed a condensate tank which had stood open for 50 years now heats its deaerator with that tank’s steam, a good use of the sink. It also means any later project aimed at the same deaerator has to be sized on what is left.
4. Blowdown: cut it, flash it, then use what remains
One audit proposed three blowdown items on the same boilers: automatic TDS control to cut blowdown from 467 to 342 kg/h, recovering the blowdown flash (59 kg/h), and using the blowdown water to preheat fuel oil to 120 °C. Each looked fine. Together they did not add up:
- The oil-preheat line valued the water at its full heat, which includes the heat already taken as flash.
- After flashing to about 0.5 bar g, the water is at about 111 °C. It cannot heat oil to 120 °C.
- Both recoveries were worked on today’s 467 kg/h. After the TDS cut only 342 kg/h remains, so both shrink by about 27 %.
Another sheet got the order right: it worked out the cut first, then the flash on the blowdown that remained. It then added condensate return without noting that returned condensate lowers the feed TDS. Blowdown falls on its own, and the TDS saving shrinks. Measures interact through water chemistry, not only through heat.
5. Cutting a stream and recovering the same stream
A pharma audit found pure steam generators purging two to ten times the correct amount and proposed purge control on every unit. Several building-level items in the same audit recovered that purge into condensate systems. Cut the purge and there is less to recover; both lines cannot be claimed in full. The audit’s guaranteed figure was about two thirds of the sum of its items, perhaps for this reason. An overlap is better worked out than hedged.
The order that keeps the total honest
- Reduce first: blowdown to a TDS figure, purge, leaks, passing traps.
- Recover the flash at the highest pressure a user can take, on what is left.
- Return the condensate left after flashing.
- Check the sink: for each saving, where does the heat end up? An open feed tank stops at 100 °C.
- Run the ceiling test. One sheet credited 217,989 kcal/h from 2,500 kg/h of condensate at about 3 bar g (143.9 kcal/kg) with make-up at 35 °C. The stream holds 2,500 × (143.9 − 35) = 272,250 kcal/h. The claim is smaller, so it passes.
Then put every claimed stream on one steam balance, each owned by one line. If two lines own the same kilogram, one of them is wrong.
What we need from you
Send us the condensate flow and pressure at each source, the flash pressure and where the flash goes, the blowdown rate with boiler and feed TDS, the feed tank temperature with make-up flow and temperature, and the list of savings in the proposal, in kg/h each. We will tell you how much of the total is new heat.
FAQ
Is it wrong to add savings from different measures?
No, as long as each kilogram and each kilocalorie is counted once. Work them out in order (reduce, recover the flash, return the condensate), each on what the step before it left, then check the total against the heat the stream actually carries.
How can I spot double counting quickly?
Add up all the heat credited to one stream and compare it with the stream's flow times its heat content above the make-up water temperature. The total must be smaller. Then ask where each saving's heat ends up: two savings that land in the same feed tank are sharing it.
Does double counting mean the project is not worth doing?
Usually not. The corrected total is smaller, and the project may still pay back well. It just has to be priced at the corrected number.